Recently, there have been a few notable “top 100 video games of all time” lists that came out. Prominent, big time, clickable lists. And while each one didn’t put “Tetris” at the top like it should have, it keeps the tradition going of magazines, websites, outlets, and publications planting their flag in the discussion while farming up those tasty clicks to increase traffic.
It’s both an exercise in critical thinking, journalism, differences of opinion, and generating online discourse. And we salute each of these very wrong lists.
So we decided to smash all of these top 100 lists together, tabulate the results, and see what the most commonly featured and highest rated games of all time ACTUALLY are. According to everyone, from the heights of IGN to the lows of WatchMojo on YouTube.
The math works out like this: we aggregated the placement of each game on the lists it showed up on, then averaged it out. But if a game showed up on most, or all, of these lists, it had a bigger weight. So ultimately, you had to appear on more top 100 lists and be ranked highly to get closer to #1.
The lists we used are from the following outlets: Kinda Funny, Giant Bomb, IGN, Polygon, Game Informer, Metacritic, IMDB, GQ, Time, Game Rant, Dextero, WatchMojo, Slant, Smash Jump, and several community polls from the Gamespot and GameFAQs community, Game Informer readers, and Reddit users.
If you don’t like the results, take it up with the concept of math. These are just cold, hard facts, bub. Well, according to journalists and fans, which is subjective of course. And very wrong, because “Tetris” is not at number one. Which is a crime.
100. “Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory” (2005)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 67th by Polgon
Our thoughts: a surprise! One of the best stealth games ever.
99. “Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots” (2008)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 22nd by IMDB
98. “Borderlands 2” (2012)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 50th by Reddit’s Reader Poll
Our take: one of the best co-op games, and by far the best in this series.
97. “Burnout 3: Takedown” (2004)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 23rd by Giant Bomb
Our take: the GOAT racing game should be higher.
96. “Bioshock Infinite” (2013)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 42nd by GI’s Reader Poll
Our take: we here at VGT stand by this still being good and not overrated.
95. “Inside” (2016)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 30th by GQ
Our take: many have tried to replicate it, but no one has come close.
94. “Horizon Zero Dawn” (2017)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 28th by GI’s Reader Poll
93. “Hitman: World of Assassination” (2021)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 14th by Giant Bomb
Our take: this includes the whole trilogy, and hell yeah, totally deserved.
92. “Mega Man 2” (1988)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 24th by MetaCritic
Our take: best soundtrack by far!
91. “Astro Bot” (2024)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 19th by Giant Bomb
Our take: a wonderful pick, even if it’s giving ‘recency bias.’
90. “Overwatch” (2016)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 29th by GI’s Reader Poll
Our take: the impact of this was seismic, even though it’s dead now.
89. “Ms. Pac-Man” (1982)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 6th by Polygon
Our take: this was the one people picked, over the original. Good.
88. “Grand Theft Auto III” (2001)
Placed on 5 Lists / Highest Ranking was 4th by Game Informer
Our take: maybe the most influential game ever made? Should be higher.
87. “Super Smash Bros. Ultimate” (2018)
Placed on 6 Lists / Highest Ranking was 18th by Kinda Funny
Our take: excellent, all-timer, but how do you follow this up?
86. “Kingdom Hearts II” (2005)
Placed on 6 Lists / Highest Ranking was 19th by GI’s Reader Poll
Our take: FUCK. YES. My sanctuary.
85. “Final Fantasy IX” (2000)
Placed on 6 Lists / Highest Ranking was 27th by WatchMojo
84. “Left 4 Dead 2” (2009)
Placed on 6 Lists / Highest Ranking was 42nd by Dextero
Our take: big time co-op games like this aren’t made and it’s a damn shame. Where is 3, Valve?
83. “Super Mario Bros.” (1985)
Placed on 6 Lists / Highest Ranking was 2nd by Game Informer
Our take: you’d think this would be higher, right?
82. “Stardew Valley” (2016)
Placed on 6 Lists / Highest Ranking was 28th by Dextero
Our take: people right now are still playing this fucking masterpiece.
81. “Persona 4” (2012)
Placed on 6 Lists / Highest Ranking was 25th by Giant Bomb
80. “Batman: Arkham Asylum” (2009)
Placed on 6 Lists / Highest Ranking was 22nd by Game Rant
Our take: the best Batman game ever. Not even close.
79. “Disco Elysium” (2019)
Placed on 6 Lists / Highest Ranking was 10th by IGN
Our take: you open the door. The knob feels warm in your hand, like someone has been here recently…
78. “Journey” (2012)
Placed on 6 Lists / Highest Ranking was 9th by Smash Jump
Our take: the pinnacle of PSN’s indie offerings
77. “Street Fighter II” (1991)
Placed on 6 Lists / Highest Ranking was 9th by Polygon
Our take: should be 70 spots higher, are you kidding me? The GOAT fighter.
76. “The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess”
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 46th by MetaCritic
Our take: it’s great, but should it have made this list? No. IOHO.
75. “Resident Evil 2” (2019)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 21st by Game Rant
Our take: the remake outdid pretty much every classic version of any of the original games.
74. “Grand Theft Auto: Vice City” (2002)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 36th by Game Rant
Our take: in five years, this won’t be on the list, because “GTA VI” will be.
73. “Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty” (2001)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 27th by Kinda Funny
Our take: metal………………..gear?
72. “StarCraft” (1998)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 13th by Polygon
71. “Hollow Knight” (2017)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 15th by Reddit’s Reader Poll
Our take: a triumph of the genre that hasn’t been matched yet.
70. “Fallout 3” (2008)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 22nd by GI’s Reader Poll
Our take: Bethesda has not made a game this good since.
69. “Mario Kart 8 Deluxe” (2017)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 18th by WatchMojo
Our take: best kart racer ever. One of the best racers ever. Pure fun.
68. “Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2” (2009)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 33rd by Reddit’s Reader Poll
Our take: we should threaten to burn down Microsoft HQ until they bring the multiplayer back remade like they did the first one.
67. “Outer Wilds” (2019)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 30th by GQ
66. “The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind” (2002)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 28th by Polygon
Our take: turns out, people still love this fucking game! Who knew.
65. “Pokémon Heart Gold and Soul Silver” (2009)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 16th by Dextero
Our take: the best Pokemon game ever, because it’s two in one.
64. “Nier: Automata” (2017)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 9th by Slant
Our take: best upskirt shots in a video game ever, that’s for sure.
63. “Marvel’s Spider-Man” (2018)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 12th by Game Rant
Our take: possibly Insomniac’s best, and the greatest super hero game.
62. “The Last of Us Part II” (2020)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 16th by Kinda Funny
61. “Red Dead Redemption” (2010)
Placed on 7 Lists / Highest Ranking was 8th by GI’s Reader Poll
Our take: Rockstar’s master work. Unrivaled.
60. “Undertale” (2015)
Placed on 8 Lists / Highest Ranking was 20th by IGN
Our take: you get to date a skeleton, what’s not to like?
59. “Grand Theft Auto IV” (2008)
Placed on 8 Lists / Highest Ranking was 4th by MetaCritic
Our take: a lot of GTA games made this list, which isn’t a surprise, but did we need them ALL?
58. “Half-Life” (1998)
Placed on 8 Lists / Highest Ranking was 28th by MetaCritic
Our take: it’s hard to remember, but this was groundbreaking in so many ways at the time.
57. “Final Fantasy X” (2001)
Placed on 8 Lists / Highest Ranking was 33rd by Smash Jump
56. “Super Mario Galaxy 2” (2010)
Placed on 8 Lists / Highest Ranking was 3rd by MetaCritic
Our take: fuck yeah they added Yoshi.
55. “Uncharted 4: A Thief’s End” (2016)
Placed on 8 Lists / Highest Ranking was 9th by Kinda Funny
Our take: the love for this is not surprising. The placement is.
54. “Uncharted 2: Among Thieves” (2009)
Placed on 8 Lists / Highest Ranking was 19th by IMDB
Our take: this is the superior Uncharted game and should be the only one on here.
53. “Pokémon Red, Blue, and Yellow” (1998)
Placed on 8 Lists / Highest Ranking was 5th by Polygon
Our take: they will remake this god damn game forever until we all die.
52. “Halo 2” (2004)
Placed on 8 Lists / Highest Ranking was 8th by Smash Jump
Our take: the best Halo.
51. “Diablo II” (2000)
Placed on 8 Lists / Highest Ranking was 28th by Game Informer
Our take: ANY game with loot hides under the shadow of this game.
50. “Elden Ring” (2022)
Placed on 8 Lists / Highest Ranking was 1st by Dextero
FUN FACT: This was the highest rated, on average, of any game by far. In that every list it made, it was a consensus top 20 performer, if not top 10 outright. But it wasn’t on enough lists to place higher…for now. In the future, this will skyrocket up the list for sure. Okay, onto the rest of the list.
49. “Super Smash Bros. Melee” (2001)
Placed on 9 Lists / Highest Ranking was 14th by Slant
48. “Super Mario Galaxy” (2007)
Placed on 9 Lists / Highest Ranking was 5th by MetaCritic
Our take: the first time Nintendo used a real orchestra for the score, somehow.
47. “Hades” (2020)
Placed on 9 Lists / Highest Ranking was 13th by IGN
Our take: the best roguelike ever.
46. “Batman: Arkham City” (2011)
Placed on 9 Lists / Highest Ranking was 15th by Game Rant
Our take: more love for this than “Asylum” shocked us.
45. “Final Fantasy VI” (1994)
Placed on 9 Lists / Highest Ranking was 2nd by Slant
44. “Fallout: New Vegas” (2010)
Placed on 9 Lists / Highest Ranking was 10th by Reddit’s Reader Poll
Our take: the love for this game is still not enough, frankly.
43. “Doom” (1993)
Placed on 9 Lists / Highest Ranking was 4th by Polygon
Our take: how is this not top five?
42. “Grand Theft Auto V” (2013)
Placed on 9 Lists / Highest Ranking was 6th by MetaCritic
Our take: it boggles the mind that this is the most popular game this far after launch.
41. “Tetris” (1989)
Placed on 9 Lists / Highest Ranking was 1st by Polygon
Our take: how is this not number one?
40. “Red Dead Redemption II” (2018)
Placed on 9 Lists / Highest Ranking was 1st by Game Rant
39. “The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker” (2003)
Placed on 10 Lists / Highest Ranking was 30th by MetaCritic
Our take: WHERE IS THE HD REMASTER FOR SWITCH 2?
38. “Portal” (2007)
Placed on 10 Lists / Highest Ranking was 17th by Polygon
Our take: a perfect video game. Perfect.
37. “Halo 3” (2007)
Placed on 10 Lists / Highest Ranking was 14th by Reddit’s Reader Poll
Our take: not a stunner that this ranked higher than “2.”
36. “Super Mario Odyssey” (2017)
Placed on 10 Lists / Highest Ranking was 1st by Giant Bomb
Our take: I would kill someone to get a sequel today.
35. “Halo: Combat Evolved” (2001)
Placed on 10 Lists / Highest Ranking was 14th by MetaCritic
Our take: taught us to use two analog sticks.
34. “Super Mario Bros. 3” (1990)
Placed on 10 Lists / Highest Ranking was 2nd by Polygon
Our take: best game on the NES.
33. “Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare” (2007)
Placed on 11 Lists / Highest Ranking was 10th by Dextero
Our take: blame this one for every game having RPG elements and perks!
32. “The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask” (2000)
Placed on 11 Lists / Highest Ranking was 1st on Slant
31. “World of Warcraft” (2004)
Placed on 11 Lists / Highest Ranking was 7th by Polygon
Our take: it’s the greatest MMO ever made, and a cultural juggernaut still.
30. “Super Metroid” (1994)
Placed on 11 Lists / Highest Ranking was 5th by IGN
Our take: Nintendo should remake this game STAT!
29. “Minecraft” (2011)
Placed on 11 Lists / Highest Ranking was 6th by WatchMojo
Our take: most copies sold for a reason. Brilliant beyond words.
28. “God of War” (2018)
Placed on 11 Lists / Highest Ranking was 4th by IMDB
Our take: a generational reboot, and the best in the series.
27. “Dark Souls” (2011)
Placed on 11 Lists / Highest Ranking was 9th by GQ
Our take: praise the sun! If only I could be so grossly incandescent.
26. “Final Fantasy VII” (1997)
Placed on 11 Lists / Highest Ranking was 2nd by Smash Jump
Our take: there’s a reason they remade it into three parts.
25. “Bloodborne” (2015)
Placed on 11 Lists / Highest Ranking was 4th by GQ
Our take: I would kill two people to get a 60fps patch today.
24. “The Witcher III: Wild Hunt” (2015)
Placed on 11 Lists / Highest Ranking was 1st by GI’s Reader Poll
Our take: best game of the generation. The DLCs alone vault this to all-timer status.
23. “Goldeneye 007” (1997)
Placed on 12 Lists / Highest Ranking was 18th by MetaCritic
Our take: this game doesn’t hold up anymore.
22. “Persona 5” (2020)
Placed on 12 Lists / Highest Ranking was 3rd by Dextero
21. “Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas” (2004)
Placed on 12 Lists / Highest Ranking was 16th by Game Rant
Our take: the best GTA because it had three cities, memes, and a banger soundtrack.
20. “Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater” (2004)
Placed on 12 Lists / Highest Ranking was 10th by IMDB
Our take: what a thrilllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllll.
19. “Castlevania: Symphony of the Night” (1997)
Placed on 12 Lists / Highest Ranking was 14th by IGN
Our take: how is this not top five? The best Metroidvania EVER.
18. “Chrono Trigger” (1995)
Placed on 12 Lists / Highest Ranking was 6th by Slant
Our take: fuck, I should play this game now…
17. “The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim” (2011)
Placed on 12 Lists / Highest Ranking was 1st by Reddit’s Reader Poll
Our take: this isn’t “most copies sold” this is best games ever. The combat just isn’t anything to write home about.
16. “The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past” (1992)
Placed on 12 Lists / Highest Ranking was 4th by IGN
15. “The Last of Us” (2013)
Placed on 12 Lists / Highest Ranking was 1st by Kinda Funny
Our take: we agree with this placement.
14. “Silent Hill 2” (2001)
Placed on 13 Lists / Highest Ranking was 8th by WatchMojo
Our take: we agree with this placement, too.
13. “Metroid Prime” (2002)
Placed on 13 Lists / Highest Ranking was 5th by Giant Bomb
Our take: Nintendo tried three times after this, and just couldn’t replicate the magic.
12. “Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic” (2003)
Placed on 13 Lists / Highest Ranking was 11th by IMDB
FUN FACT: the sequel almost made this top 100 list!
11. “Portal 2” (2011)
Placed on 13 Lists / Highest Ranking was 2nd by Kinda Funny
Our take: the funniest game ever made.
10. “Bioshock” (2007)
Placed on 13 Lists / Highest Ranking was 9th by GI’s Reader Poll
Our take: should be a top ten game all time. Just so original and hauntingly beautiful.
9. “Super Mario World” (1991)
Placed on 13 Lists / Highest Ranking was 2nd by IGN
My take: this is my favorite game ever made. Platformers peaked with this shit.
8. “Metal Gear Solid” (1998)
Placed on 13 Lists / Highest Ranking was 3rd by WatchMojo
7. “Mass Effect 2” (2010)
Placed on 13 Lists / Highest Ranking was 4th by GI’s Reader Poll
Our take: RIP Bioware. This was their magnum opus.
6. “The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild” (2017)
Placed on 13 Lists / Highest Ranking was 9th by GI’s Reader Poll
Our take: should be top ten, for sure.
5. “Shadow of the Colossus” (2005)
Placed on 14 Lists / Highest Ranking was 4th by Slant
Our take: quite stunning how high this landed! Much beloved.
4. “Half-Life 2” (2004)
Placed on 14 Lists / Highest Ranking was 5th by Smash Jump
Our take: should be top five, for sure.
3. “Resident Evil 4” (2005)
Placed on 14 Lists / Highest Ranking was 8th by Slant
Our take: should be top five, of course.
2. “Super Mario 64” (1996)
Placed on 15 Lists / Highest Ranking was 1st by WatchMojo
Our take: invented 3D in our consciousness, even though it wasn’t the actual first. Most speed runs of any game, also!
- “The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time” (1998)
Placed on 15 Lists / Highest Ranking was 1st by MetaCritic
Our take: was there any other choice?
Image credit: “Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas,” “Fallout: New Vegas,” “Nier: Automata,” “Half-Life 2”





Leave a Reply