This guest post is written by Jack Thomas Lawson.

Editor’s note: Yes we did bully Jack into putting Pauline up much higher. Sorry buddy, our site our rules. She is a rock star and New Donk City is a major metropolitan area!


Real elections have one flaw: the candidates exist. Video game mayors fix that. None of them will knock on your door with a flyer, and every one is fictional. (I am staying out of the real races. Please stop asking.)

Here are the rules. I scored each mayor out of ten on three questions. What did they get done? Would I trust them with a budget? How many scandals follow them around? Higher score, higher rank. I checked every title against the games, so anyone who was not actually a mayor got cut.

Every town gets the mayor it deserves. Video game towns get whoever picked up the controller. Pick the one who shows up, fixes the thing, and pays for the bridge.

Note: I did not replay all of these to write this. Where a game’s details are fuzzy, I kept the joke small. Also, Tom Nook did not make it. He is just a landlord/crime boss/father with excellent PR.


11. Mayor McDonough, Diamond City (‘Fallout 4’): 3.5/10

He runs a walled city out of a baseball stadium. Outsiders stay outside, and ghouls are not welcome. He is also a super mutant. (Yes, that is a spoiler for a 2015 game. The statute of limitations has run.)

A super mutant who bans ghouls and swears he is a regular human has a policy that fights his own biography. I count that as a scandal. I count it twice.

Verdict: No. Also, no.

10. Mayor Dotour, Clock Town (‘The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask’): 4/10

A moon with a face is falling on his town. Every morning at 10, Dotour sits in a meeting while Mutoh and Captain Viscen argue about canceling the Carnival of Time. On the final day, what settles it is Mutoh threatening to call his wife.

That is the whole emergency plan. The moon is coming, and the deciding vote is a phone call to Madame Aroma.

But: wear the Couple’s Mask and his head clears. He lets residents decide whether to stay or run, and he hands you a Piece of Heart. (His son Kafei is still missing, and Dotour may know more than he says.)

Verdict: Decisive only with accessories.

9. The SimCity Mayor (‘SimCity’): 4.5/10

You zone the districts, set the taxes, and keep a monster button within reach. The city grows beautifully. Then you get bored.

Every disaster is self-reported. I trust this mayor with a budget only because nobody else is around to hold it. (The tornado was a choice. Own it.)

Verdict: Competent until bored.

8. Tortimer, Animal Crossing (‘Animal Crossing: New Leaf’): 5.5/10

He ran the festivals for years and kept the town cheerful. Then he retired to a vacation island and handed the job to whoever stepped off the train. No scandals, clean conscience.

The succession plan is a stranger with a bug net and a bag of Bells. Somehow it worked.

Verdict: Earned the beach.

7. Hancock, Goodneighbor (‘Fallout 4’): 6/10

Goodneighbor has no walls and asks no questions. Hancock is a ghoul in a tricorn hat, and his policy on chems is yes. He is also the only mayor in the Commonwealth who will let you in, including the ghouls Diamond City turns away.

A man who takes in the people the stadium rejected has my attention. I would give him petty cash. I would also locate the exits.

Verdict: Fine for a night.

6. Mayor Bo, Ordon Village (‘The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess’): 6.5/10

Bo is the only mayor on this list who hosts a secret sumo match in his own house. You show up after failing to climb Death Mountain, and he wrestles you. He loses by a hair, then hands over the Iron Boots he says he used to beat Gor Coron.

That is a transfer of village property with no paperwork. His daughter Ilia calls him on it, which makes his strongest opposition a teenager. She is right.

Note: the village children get abducted early on, which is a bad week for any mayor. They are all home by the credits. (There is also a goat situation. There is always a goat situation.)

Verdict: Fun. Fix the Iron Boots paperwork.

5. Mayor Lewis, Pelican Town (‘Stardew Valley’): 7/10

He asks a stranger to repair the Community Center and says thank you. Most mayors cannot manage that. His scandal count is two: a pair of lucky purple shorts that go missing, and a long-running secret with Marnie that he describes as nothing.

A town this small cannot afford a bigger scandal. Joja is already parked at the edge of the map, waiting for one.

Verdict: Sure. Return the shorts.

4. Mike Haggar, Metro City (‘Final Fight’): 7.5/10

Former wrestler. He cleaned up crime by punching it. Due process holds zero interest for him, but he will personally retrieve your daughter, which is more than most city councils offer.

I do not know where the police budget went. I assume his arms. He loses a point because the platform is one issue, and the issue is hands.

Verdict: Yes, and keep your daughter close.

3. Lucas Simms, Megaton (‘Fallout 3’): 8/10

Why does this man keep getting left off lists? He is the mayor and the sheriff of a town built around a live atomic bomb. He still greets every stranger at the gate with a polite warning instead of a bullet.

The housing code is sheds on girders around a nuclear warhead. The town is named after the warhead. A church worships it, and its leader, Confessor Cromwell, baptizes himself in the irradiated water at the crater. Simms runs all of this like an ordinary Tuesday.

Then you arrive, and he does not send you after a lost brahmin. He asks the stranger with the Pip-Boy to disarm the bomb. Do it, and he pays you in caps and gives you a house with a robot butler. (No landlord I have heard of has ever done that.)

Scandals: he holds two offices, which is either a conflict of interest or a staffing decision in a town of sheds. But: his whole security plan depends on a Vault Dweller who might take Mr. Burke’s detonator instead. Do that, and Megaton is gone. Moira Brown survives as a ghoul. Nobody else does.

I give him an 8 anyway. Running a nuke is harder than anything Diamond City ever asked of anyone.

Verdict: Yes. Defuse the bomb and keep your karma.

2. Pauline, New Donk City (‘Super Mario Odyssey’): 8.5/10

Look, I owe you an explanation. Pauline started in 1981 as a woman called ‘Lady’, carried up a building by a giant ape. Decades later she runs the skyline and everyone in it. That is a career arc.

Her record in ‘Super Mario Odyssey’ is a crisis response. Bowser’s minions are attacking. A Mechawiggler is stealing the city’s electricity. Her answer: ask a plumber to round up four band members and restore the power so the festival can go ahead.

That is infrastructure, outsourcing, and event planning in one memo. A whole city of New Donkers hears ‘Jump Up, Super Star!’ in the street, and I still hum it. Do not bring me complaints about the festival or the song.

What about the budget? Look up. A city that tall cost real money, and the lights came back on. The receipts are the skyline.

Scandals: none, unless you count the ape. That was settled decades ago.

Verdict: Yes. Re-elect her and jump up.

1. The Player, ‘Animal Crossing: New Leaf’: 9/10

You got the job at a train station by clerical error. Then you passed ordinances for years and paid for the bridges out of your own wallet. It is the only budget policy I have ever believed in.

Zero scandals. One flaw: there was no election. There has never been an election. I would vote for you, and I would like the chance.

Verdict: Yes. Please hold a vote.


Image Credit: “Mario Kart Tour”

One response to “11 Video Game Mayors Ranked By Who We’d Actually Vote For”

  1. Awesome well researched.And written.

Leave a Reply

Trending