Now 50 years old, “Rocky” is one of Hollywood’s quintessential success stories, on either side of the screen. The underdog boxing classic spawned five direct sequels and three major spinoffs (by way of the “Creed” trilogy), but making-of saga “I Play Rocky,” from “Green Book’s” Peter Farrelly, may as well be another entry in the franchise. Which is to say: the TIFF premiere (and People’s Choice Award runner up) leans on classic imagery to tell its story, one heavily dependent on our familiarity with the film and its writer-star, Sylvester Stallone. That’s really all there is to it.

For some, that sense of recognition might be enough. But on its own merits, “I Play Rocky” is a mechanical, anticlimactic movie with only a few fun beats to speak of, yielding one of the mildest “crowd-pleasers” in recent memory.

Like with any biopic about a familiar figure, its mainstream appeal will likely come down to casting. We love a good impression. Don’t we, folks? In that vein, 27-year-old actor Anthony Ippolito — who also played Al Pacino in Paramount’s “The Godfather” making-of series, “The Offer” — fills out the muscular contours of your vague memories of Stallone. It’s a neat party trick, because he really does nail the actor’s guttural rasp, but for a film where people constantly reference Stallone’s hidden soulfulness, the young upstart doesn’t go the distance.

Beginning with its subject’s days as a movie theater usher and softcore porn actor in New York, the film — written by Peter Gamble — captures Stallone’s proximity to the mainstream business and his interest in the movies. He makes occasional comments here and there about what little detail he might fix in a new release, but like with his alleged depth and dynamism, Stallone’s hidden intellect is something referenced ad nauseum, but seldom felt or seen.

It becomes quickly apparent that although this is technically a Stallone story — one you’d be forgiven for thinking he produced, given its hagiographic nature — it’s really about trying to re-capture “Rocky’s” lightning in a bottle, as an underdog success story buoyed by romance. The first indication is when Stallone first hobbles up to sweetheart coworker and wannabe photographer Sasha Czack (AnnaSophia Robb) and begins hopelessly flirting. There’s a certain charm to it, thanks in part to the pair’s chemistry, but mostly because it recalls the framing and rhythm of any number of “Rocky” scenes, where Stallone’s dark-horse boxer Rocky Balboa rocks up to mousey love interest Adrian (Talia Shire).

You might expect some kind of creative transposition when Stallone finally pens the movie. But despite his numerous claims of “this is my story,” there’s little to suggest a hint of reality in what he writes, or any kind of inspiration from Czack, even though she types out his handwritten pages when the couple moves to L.A. It’s hard not to feel for the radiant Robb, who’s reduced to a retrograde supporting wife, a role that pivots around the idea that, with the right cornermen, Stallone can be a solo champion. But that’s not what moviemaking is.

Although there are hurdles in Stallone’s path, no collaborator — not resourceful “Rocky” director John G. Avildsen (Jay Duplass), nor any of his co-stars including Shire (played by Kiki Seto) or Carl Weathers (a firecracker Stephan James) — appears to have any creative autonomy of their own, or any meaningful input. Stallone is the only person making any real decisions on the ramshackle, sub-million-dollar shoot, which makes for a fun, against-all-odds narrative at times, but grows quickly stale, since even this fictitious Stallone lacks the interiority to make “Rocky” happen.

“I Play Rocky” has a couple of remarkably fun comedic beats — a combination of Ippolito and James’s body language, and Farrelly knowing just where to put the camera — but these are largely fleeting. For the most part, it’s a rote re-telling of foregone conclusions, where producers like Irwin Winkler (P.J. Bryne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell) are brought over to Stallone’s side by what feels like annoying stubbornness rather than any creative spark.

That Stallone wants to play the part of Balboa despite having few screen credits is, in fact, what really happened. But its presentation here is a mere simulacrum of reality, presented in emotionally empty terms, where little feels like it’s at stake. There’s never a moment of doubt or devastation holding Stallone back. He’s persistent in a way a robot is persistent, owing to its programming, rather than through reasoning, or dilemmatic decision-making.

It’s hard to be irked by some of the political specifics the film contains (an Amazon production where unions are a minor villain? Shocker) if only because little in “I Play Rocky” risks catharsis enough to be offensive in the process. But if the film has a major antagonist, it’s Tracy Letts as composite studio suit Sandy Maddox, who plays the role of the record company naysayer in your average music biopic, and tries to sabotage Stallone out of the part. However, the two never interact on screen, which — regardless of production realities; Maddox is fictional after all — makes for unsatisfying drama.

When it comes time to actually impress Maddox with the finished product, the result is deeply underwhelming. Not because Farrelly and co. don’t adequately ape the actual “Rocky” (these are about the only scenes with any real verve), but because “I Play Rocky” depends so heavily on the original’s iconography, for its rousing moments, that it forgets to craft any of its own. This leads to the movie simply petering out all of a sudden, rather than creating an actual ending.

The conclusion to the story, of course, already exists within our collective cultural consciousness, leaving us to fill in most of the gaps. We know what “Rocky” went on to become; that people will buy a ticket to “I Play Rocky” in the first place is proof positive of its legacy. Anything beyond this, however, constitutes lazy popcorn filmmaking that doesn’t so much rest on its laurels as it does stand on the shoulders of giants before clumsily slipping off and landing face first on the Philadelphia concrete. You’re much better off re-watching “Rocky” instead.


Image credit: “I Play Rocky”

This guest post is written by the best in the business, world class film critic Siddhant Adlakha.

One response to “TIFF Review: ‘I Play Rocky’ Plays The Hits, And Not Much Else”

  1. […] TIFF Review: ‘I Play Rocky’ Plays The Hits, And Not Much Else […]

Trending